Maryland when the waiver of rights is made with a complete understanding of “the nature of the right and how it would apply in general circumstances-even though the defendant may not know the specific detailed consequences invoking it.” Ultimately, the Supreme Court in Ruiz held that the government is not required to disclose material impeachment evidence to a criminal defendant prior to entering into a plea deal with the defendant. United States that a guilty plea is effectively a waiver of the constitutional guarantees that accompany a jury trial the guilty plea must be voluntary as well as knowing and intelligent, “done with sufficient awareness of the relevant circumstances and likely consequences.” According to the Supreme Court’s opinion in Ruiz, a waiver of one’s constitutional rights, including a guilty plea made by a criminal defendant, will typically be considered knowing, intelligent, and sufficiently aware under Brady v. While it certainly seems that evidence which proves a criminal defendant’s innocence is “material to either the defendant’s guilt or punishment,” the issue remains whether the prosecution in a criminal case must disclose such exculpatory evidence to the defendant during the plea bargaining process, prior to trial. Maryland, the Brady doctrine maintains that there is a constitutional right to procedural due process requiring the prosecution to disclose all evidence favorable to the defendant during a criminal trial. Pursuant to the Supreme Court’s holding in Brady v. Ruiz, suggests that the prosecution in a criminal case could be acting in violation of the Brady doctrine when it withholds exculpatory evidence from a defendant who ultimately pleads guilty. Meanwhile, although the Seventh, Ninth, and Tenth Circuits have not affirmatively held that such a right exists, they have each concluded that the ruling in a prior Supreme Court case, United States v. The Fifth Circuit recently joined the First, Second, and Fourth Circuits by holding that a criminal defendant is not entitled to exculpatory evidence in the prosecution’s possession prior to pleading guilty. Emily Westerfield, Associate Member, University of Cincinnati Law Reviewįederal courts are currently split on the timing of when exculpatory evidence must be disclosed under Brady.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |